72-Year-Old Sikh Grandmother Detained by ICE During Routine Check-in
Yo, have you guys heard about the shocking situation unfolding in California with Bibi Harjit Kaur? This 72-year-old grandmother was recently detained by ICE during what was supposed to be a routine check-in. For over 30 years, Bibi Harjit Kaur has lived and worked in the United States, regularly complying with these check-ins, a testament to her consistent engagement with the system. At her last check-in a few weeks ago, everything changed. Despite no apparent policy shifts, she was abruptly taken into custody by ICE. Her lawyer, Deepak Ahluwalia, has spoken out about the inhumane treatment she experienced. Imagine a 72-year-old woman, with bad knees, being roughly handled and held in a jail cell for days—a deeply unsettling experience for anyone, let alone an elderly individual.
Naturally, I’ve seen comments online suggesting it’s her fault for not having her paperwork in order. But at what point do we allow for compassionate grounds? When someone has contributed to society for over three decades, with their entire family established here, and poses no risk, shouldn’t there be a pathway for them to remain? I’m not an immigration lawyer, and I won’t pretend to understand the intricate nuances of the U.S. immigration system. However, the recurring theme of families being torn apart by ICE is profoundly disturbing.
This situation, and others like it, highlights a troubling hypocrisy in our political discourse. We’ve seen similar heartbreaking scenarios affecting other communities, particularly Mexican families. Yet, many, including some within the Punjabi and Sikh communities who align with conservative ideals, often take a hardline stance: “If you don’t do it the right way, you have to go.” But when these harsh policies impact their own community, suddenly it’s a different story.
This “it affects them, not us” mentality is one of the biggest problems I have with contemporary politics. We often vote based on what we perceive will benefit us directly, failing to recognize that what impacts one community today could very well impact ours tomorrow. It’s a fundamental human fallacy to get so caught up in “what’s best for me” rather than “what’s best for our community, or the greater community.” People don’t seem to realize that those who advocate for mass deportations often don’t differentiate between various immigrant groups. Look at the anti-immigration sentiment in places like Canada; even some Punjabis are now voting for parties that promise to deport everyone, seemingly unaware that they might be next in line.
This pervasive hypocrisy within society is truly saddening. I sincerely hope that Bibi Harjit Kaur and her family get this situation sorted out, and that the community rallies around her. Some might suggest that being sent back to India wouldn’t be “so bad,” but her entire life and family have been here for over 30 years. What would she do there? It’s a messed-up situation, highlighting the critical importance of paying attention to politics and carefully considering who we vote for.
Peace.
View On: